Highkey Healthy

Banana Cream Mini Pies (GF, Paleo, Vegan)

paleo vegan banana cream

Oh how I’ve missed my kitchen. If you follow me on instagram then you know I moved this last weekend. My husband and I sold our southern oregon house and made the 5 hour move back to Portland, OR (I went to college up here so Portland is already familiar). This first week here has been a dream, it’s been sunny and super warm (so unusual) making it so nice to walk and skate around getting to know our new neighborhood! Also our neighborhood is a dog meca so you know I’m thrilled!

But the nature of moving leads to a lot of eating out, and my tummy ain’t happy.  One of the hardest parts about having dietary restrictions is all the eye candy around that you can’t eat. Portland has arguably the best food scene on the west coast but I only get to enjoy a portion of it. I never let my restrictions stop me from eating at new places but it’s annoying not getting to order what you really want. So while I can’t eat everything I want, I can take inspiration from those places and come home and make those same dishes or treats but in a way that fits my diet.

First things first, fill that sweet tooth! Now that my kitchen is put back together I can present you my most recent creation. Having these in the house makes all the eating out struggles A-OKAY. Paleo vegan BANANA CREAM MINI PIES! Yum! 

paleo vegan banana cream

I’m into anything mini, but also it’s a great way to portion control because while these mini pies are healthy they’re still full of sugar and should be enjoyed in moderation!


These banana cream mini pies are not to be missed out on, they’re seriously delicious, and incredibly easy to make.  

The crust is adapted from my Chocolate Raspberry Tart Recipe (< another super easy delicious treat btw). It’s crunchy and chewy at the same time, hard to believe it’s so healthy.

The filling is a creamy banana pudding, and coconut whip cream!

The pudding is a blend of banana, nut milk, potato starch, sugar and vanilla and the coconut whip cream is made from whole fat coconut cream and a little added sugar. So simple yet so delicious!

paleo vegan banana cream
paleo vegan banana cream
paleo vegan banana cream

This is my go-to spring and summer dessert, perfect for BBQ’s and get togethers seeing as it’s light, refreshing, easy to serve and sweet and indulgent (they were a real hit at my recent going away party)!


Paleo vegan banana cream pies, perfectly creamy, and healthy with just the right amount of sweetness, crunch and fluff! 

AUTHOR Highkey Healthy



  • 2/3 cup blanched almond meal
  • 2 tbsp maple syrup
  • 1 tbsp coconut oil
  • 1/2 cup raw whole almonds

Banana Pudding

  • 1 tbsp potato starch *
  • 1/2 cup dairy free milk *
  • 1 tbsp cane sugar *
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
  • 1 banana or 1/2 cup
  • pinch of salt

Coconut Whip Cream

  • Full fat coconut milk from a can refrigerate can
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 1-2 tbsp powdered sugar


  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.

  2. In a food processor blend all of your crust ingredients until the whole almonds are in small chunks (see image).

  3. Line your muffin tin with liners (greasing the pan will not work).

  4. Equally disperse your crust mixture into your muffin tin, it will look like a lot until you press it down. Using your fingers press the crust onto the bottom and sides of your tin. 

  5. Use a fork to puncture the bottom of your crust...three times on each bottom. 

  6. Bake for 10-13 minutes until golden brown on edges.  Once baked set aside to fully cool. 

  7. While that is baking, in a small sauce pan whisk together your potato starch, milk, sugar and vanilla. Place over medium heat, use a plastic spatula to constantly stir and scrap the sides and bottom. In about 2-5 minutes the mixture will thicken, you want it jiggly, and the consistency of thick jam. Too thick is just fine, too thin will result in a runny pie. 

  8. Place into a bowl, cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate until cool (about 1-2 hrs).

  9.  In the mean time make the coconut whip cream. Remove the can of coconut cream from the fridge, carefully scoop out the hard white part of the coconut cream leaving behind the liquid part. Use a hand mixer to whip the coconut cream until soft and airy. Add vanilla extract and powdered sugar. You decide how sweet you want the whip cream, add powdered sugar 1/2 tbsp at a time until you reach the desired sweetness (I like about 1 tbsp per 8 oz of coconut cream). Set aside. 

  10. Once your pudding is cool, in a high speed blender or food processor blend your banana and pinch of salt until smooth. Add your pudding into the blender and blend until just combined. 

  11. Remove the paper liners from the crusts. 

  12. Spoon the banana pudding into the mini crusts. Place back into the refrigerator to let it set up (about 1-2 hrs). 

  13. Once they're cool and ready to eat top with your coconut whip cream. (I re-whip my coconut whip cream before serving to keep it nice and fluffy.)

     Optional: top with banana slices.


Makes 6 mini banana cream pies. Feel free to double the recipe. 

Crust: Do not make any substitutes. The blanched almond flour and raw almonds are both needed to make the crust work. 

Potato starch: can substitute for corn starch, but will not be paleo. Do not use arrowroot starch, it will not work. 

Milk: I have made this recipe with homemade cashew milk and Native Forest "Simple" coconut milk, both turned out great. Both are guar gum and carrageenan free, which I talk about why I don't eat HERE.

Sugar: if you are strictly paleo and do not eat cane sugar, sub for coconut sugar. This will yield a more caramel flavor, but still delish. 

Banana: you want your banana perfectly ripe, no green, some brown spotting is great. Do not use under ripe bananas! 

The filling will turn light brown from the bananas, I recommend serving within 24 hrs. 

Coconut whip cream: I have the best luck with Field Day brand, full fat. If you've never made coconut whip cream read this first


I’m Kelly

The owner of Highkey Healthy. Let’s talk! Comment below,  if you have any questions and if you try a recipe, tell me know what you think! xoxo

recipe image
Recipe Name
Paleo and Vegan Banana Cream Mini Pies
Author Name
Published On
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)

Post a Comment